NOT IN NEGERI SEMBILAN, MALACCA, JOHORE OR IN PAHANG.

PAS has retained Permatang Pasir.
This comes as a no surprise and is a no brainer.
When DAP sounded it‘s clarion to canvass support from the all-important non- Muslims votes, they rallied around.
It is DAP and PR that they have voted for and not PAS.
This would be the same in Perak and perhaps in Selangor.

If Permatang Paisir had been somewhere out there in Negeri Sembilan, Malacca, Johore or in Pahang and should the voter's ethnic composition remains more or less the same, PAS can kiss the/any victory goodbye.
Even DAP with LGE would find it hard to get the pivotal votes of the non-Muslim - Not when there are Islamist donkeys like Hassan Ali and Nasrudin Hassan running around - terrorizing their moderate co religionist and at the same time brazenly flaunting their intolerance to the other 48% of the population of Malaysia.

The Umno run Federal Government has 2 "more than willing" overt allies inside the PAS and PR power structure.

Pas state commissioner and state executive councillor Datuk Dr Hasan Ali is "digging his own grave in politics" following his recent announcement empowering mosque officials to detain Muslims who drink alcohol in the state.
State speaker and DAP assemblyman for Sungai Pinang Teng Chang Khim said people would view Hasan's move as a "fundamentalist" policy.
"I don't want to interfere in Muslim affairs but Hasan seems to think that he speaks for all Muslims," he said when asked to comment on Hasan's announcement on Monday.

Karyawan president Freddie Fernandez has out at the PAS Youth which wants a ban on the Michael Learns to Rock (MLTR) concert in Genting Highlands in September.
He disputed the movement’s reason — that the concert was taking place during Ramadan.
PAS Youth chief Nasrudin Hassan Tantawi had issued a statement condemning the concert, calling it “an insult to all Muslims in the country during Ramadan”, adding they might demonstrate to get the concert stopped.
“PAS tries to get concerts banned any time of the year. For them, every concert is bad,” said Fernandez